Access Restriction

Author Atwood, Michael E. ♦ Ramsey, H. Rudy ♦ Van Doren, James R.
Source ACM Digital Library
Content type Text
Publisher Association for Computing Machinery (ACM)
File Format PDF
Language English
Subject Keyword Behavioral research ♦ Flowcharts ♦ Software design ♦ Software documentation ♦ Human factors ♦ Program design languages
Abstract An experiment was performed to assess the relative merits of program design languages (PDLs) and flowcharts as techniques for the development and documentation of detailed designs for computer programs. The use of a PDL by a software designer, for the development and description of a detailed program design, produced better results than did the use of flowcharts. Specifically, the designs appeared to be of significantly better quality, involving more algorithmic or procedural detail, than those produced using flowcharts. In addition, flowchart designs exhibited considerably more abbreviation and other space-saving practices than did PDL designs, with a possible adverse effect on their readability. When equivalent, highly readable designs were presented to subjects in both PDL and flowchart form, no pattern of short-term or long-term differences in comprehension of the design was observed. No significant differences were detected in the quality or other properties of programs written as implementations of the designs. Subjective ratings indicated a mild preference for PDLs. Overall, the results suggest that software design performance and designer-programmer communication might be significantly improved by the adoption of informal PDLs rather than flowcharts as a standard documentation method for detailed computer program designs.
Description Affiliation: Bell Telephone Labs, Denver, CO (Atwood, Michael E.) || Oklahoma State Univ., Stillwater (Van Doren, James R.) || ITT Programming Technology Center, Statford (Ramsey, H. Rudy)
Age Range 18 to 22 years ♦ above 22 year
Educational Use Research
Education Level UG and PG
Learning Resource Type Article
Publisher Date 2005-08-01
Publisher Place New York
Journal Communications of the ACM (CACM)
Volume Number 26
Issue Number 6
Page Count 5
Starting Page 445
Ending Page 449

Open content in new tab

   Open content in new tab
Source: ACM Digital Library